At first glance, it’s not bad. I started thinking about other variants, tho. “Make America Great” because the “again” part is the retrograde perspective that in some sense is racist and ignorant of the mistakes we’ve made.
Trying it with yours becomes “Make America Feel Good” : nope. We’re already using that for legalizing pot.
How about this: “Don’t Be Stupid” you can get the Shredded Wheat commercials back and everyone would vote for Frank Druffle.