Personal experience is that you're both right and both missing the clue: all generations have "all of the above". It's just that the fanatical competicism over competing fanaticisms (and marketing) has conditioned us to label everyone however it is most convenient so we can target them (commercially or violently). It's what civilization has been doing since the first god was invented to justify killing people as targets. The problem is that the aggressive ones get to the labelmakers first, and that's Capitalism in a nutshell: labelmakers and bullies all the way to the magic Aristocrat in the Sky.